Houston Astros: Should Jon Singleton Start At First?

Remember Jon Singleton, the top prospect acquired in the Hunter Pence trade several years ago?

I do, but many Astros fan forgot how well-regarded of a prospect he was in that trade. And frankly, it’s deserved.

Since becoming an Astro, Singleton has been in the news more for his off-the-field issues, though it appears as if he’s past that for now.

While on the field, Singleton has struggled as well. In 114 games with the Astros the last two seasons, the former Philly prospect is hitting just .171 with a .621 OPS. He’s been a big disappointment since signing a long-term deal with the Astros that will earn him $2 million each of the next few seasons.

More from House of Houston

But for Singleton, this winter and spring training could be his last chance in Houston.

The Astros non-tendered last year’s first baseman, Chris Carter, leaving a hole in their lineup at first base. Though Singleton may have the lead for the job as of this post, both Tyler White and A.J. Reed are breathing down his neck.

White wasn’t the top prospect Singleton was, but all he’s done in the Minor Leagues is hit. Reed, on the other hand, is that same prospect Singleton was a few years ago and could steal Singleton’s job with a strong spring training of his own. He’s been mashing since being drafted and has the Major League pop the Astros seak at first base.

The good news for Singleton is that the Astros aren’t likely to hand Reed the opening day job. That leaves the position open for either himself or White.

What Singleton does have going for him is the contract he signed. The Astros aren’t likely to give up on him, considering the financial promise they gave to him a year and a half years ago. He’s owed another $2 million each season until after the 2018 season. Following that season he has three club options in a row that escalate over time.

So the 24-year old Singleton should be this year’s starter at first base, unless they find a trade partner. Assuming he’s an Astro on opening day and no other free agent signing occurs, Singleton will likely man first base, at least that’s what GM Jeff Luhnow said last week.

Last year, when the Astros started 18-7 last season, Chris Carter was the primary first baseman. He was hitting only .159 after those 25 games, but the Astros thought Carter would turn things around like he did in 2014. In Carter’s case, he bought himself plenty of time to try and prove that he could right the ship.